Posted by: philosopherouge | October 22, 2007

Vampyr (Dreyer, 1932)



I watched Vampyr last night, and I was unfortunately quite disappointed. I think part of it can be linked to the amount of text used, and the poor translation of the film (I’m not fluent in German, but I know they leave out a few passages of dialogue that from what I pick up, are rather important… and the copy that I have has annoying giant block letter subtitles that take up literally half the screen). Suffice to say, I wish they hadn’t tried to make this a sound picture, because I think it would have been better as a straight out silent film. The excess of text though, is also a problem and it ruins the pacing of the film. Especially compared to something like Murnau’s Nosferatu, there isn’t even scarcity and precision in what is presented to us. All this add up to why I had so much trouble integrating myself into the film… my concentration just kept getting interrupted. The story itself wasn’t particularly thrilling either, but I think it would have been greatly improved if these problems had been sorted out.

That being said, despite not being enamoured with the film, I loved the strength of the imagery. Dreyer doesn’t use the close-up as much as I expected (or would have liked), especially in context of La Passion de Jeanne D’Arc being the only other film of his I have seen. However, even in their limited utilization, they’re played with great effect. It’s the borrowing from German expressionism, however, that’s the strongest. The interplay of shadows as “demons”, and the use of extreme angles, stairs and emotion over logic. The film is at it’s best when it forgoes plot, and character in exchange for these strong emotion driven imagery. One scene in particular stands out as one of the characters is “dead” and is put into a casket with a window and as the body is carried away, we see what the corpse sees. These scenes are pure silent cinema, relying entirely on the power of the visual image rather than on character or plot. The film should have focused on these impressions, rather than on the facts. Sound in this case, becomes reality, and becomes what grounds the film when it should be flying high.



  1. This is the only Dreyer film I’ve seen that I don’t aboslutely hate (everything else, especially his sound films, are insufferable).

    I agree with a lot of what you say.

  2. That’s too bad, I hate hating films. This really was dissapointing though, it took a lot of effort to find something good. The visuals are interesting, not much else.

  3. Will you try to blog at CCoC once in awhile? You have yet to restore my faith in your blogging.

  4. I got sick this week and didn’t end up watching much. I’ve played a bit at our blog, but I don’t know what the intention of it is? Is it just an ordinary one, or is there more of a focus.

  5. Focus? We don’t know yet. The idea is to post whatever you feel like posting until we can build some kind of momentum.

    This means: don’t feel inhibited. Don’t feel you have to write a normal blog post. Write whatever the heck you want. I encourage you to write something you’d never think of writing for one of your blogs. Eh?

  6. I’m catching up on my faves on my blogroll, so I’m a bit behind on comments (and it looks like you’ve had a bunch of great posts of late).

    Though I essentially agree with much of your post on “Vampyr”, I liked the visuals and surrealism in the film so much, it made my Top 31 Films That Give Me The Willies. There’s enough of the unsettling visual storytelling to lift the creep factor way up there for me. I do wonder though…If this had been a silent film, would it have been even more creepy? Probably yes, since it would have been less verbose and more visual.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: